Miami commissioners take a final vote Nov. 19 on animal cruelty fines of up to $7,500. The plan also limits dogs left alone on balconies and tightens leash rules.
Fines for animal cruelty in Miami would jump from a top rate of a few hundred dollars to as much as $7,500 under an ordinance the Miami City Commission takes up for a final vote Thursday, Nov. 19.
The same package would bar owners from leaving a dog alone on a balcony overnight or without shade or water. A second ordinance rewrites the city’s leash rules for dogs on sidewalks, in parks and in shared building areas.
Both passed on first reading 5-0 on Oct. 22, “with modification(s),” according to the city’s legislative record for the fines ordinance and the record for the leash ordinance. The city has not yet posted the modified text. The details below are from the version on the city’s site, so the final wording could differ.
The second-reading vote was announced in a city clerk’s notice of proposed ordinances published Monday.
Why the fines are going up
The Florida Legislature raised the ceiling on local animal cruelty and animal control fines this year in HB 559, the ordinance says. Cities may now charge up to $2,500 for a first violation, $5,000 for a second and $7,500 for a third or later one.
The ordinance says the city “has observed an increase in incidents involving animal cruelty and the use of animals in aggressive or unlawful activities.” It does not give figures. All five commissioners are listed as sponsors.
What the fines would be
For cruelty and the new balcony rule, the proposed fines are:
| Offense | Proposed fine |
|---|---|
| First | $2,500 |
| Second | $5,000 |
| Third or later | $7,500 |
That top tier covers four sections of the animal chapter, including the city’s cruelty rules and the new balcony rule. The city’s animal fines now run from $50 to $500, the ordinance says.
For other animal code violations, the draft raises the fines for a person who does not contest the citation:
| Offense | Fine now | Proposed fine |
|---|---|---|
| First | $50 | $100 |
| Second | $200 | $250 |
| Third or later | $400 | $500 |
The draft also changes how offenses are counted:
- each day and each animal would count as a separate offense
- the city would look back five years for earlier violations when deciding whether an offense is a first, second or third
- the separate, higher fines for people who contest a citation and lose would be removed
The new rules for dogs
The fines ordinance adds these rules to the city code:
- Balconies. An unattended dog may not be left on a balcony for more than an hour between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m., without shade or water, or during a severe National Weather Service advisory.
- Bad weather. Leaving a dog exposed to the elements during a severe weather advisory would count as cruelty.
- Pet sales. Anyone selling or giving away a pet must first check the Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s Animal Abuse Registry.
- Parking lots. Pet sales in a parking lot or other public place would be banned unless the law allows them.
The leash ordinance says a dog owner may not let a dog:
- into a public park or onto a public beach unless the law specifically allows it
- commit a nuisance on a public sidewalk, a shared hallway of an apartment building or the floor of a store or office building
- run loose on public property, in the common areas of a building, or on someone else’s property without permission
- become a public threat, which includes chasing cars or people
Dogs may run off leash in park areas where that is specifically allowed, if a competent person is supervising them. Service animals and police dogs are exempt. The ordinance says it is meant to clear up “confusion” over whether the city’s leash rule applies to dogs on public property at all.
Also on the Nov. 19 agenda
Other items the city clerk has advertised for the same meeting include:
- a resolution to skip competitive bidding for the city’s self-service bike rental and sharing program from Deco Bike LLC (notice)
- a no-bid purchase of information and emergency kiosks for the Department of Resilience and Public Works (notice)
- up to $400,000 a year for a youth mentoring program run by Big Brothers Big Sisters of Miami (notice)
- easements for Florida Power & Light electric vehicle chargers at Charlie DeLucca Park and Gibson Park (notice, notice)
- a final vote on a new Calle Ocho Parking Improvement Trust Fund (notice)
What it means for you
If you own a dog and live in an apartment or condo with a balcony, the overnight limit and the shade and water rule would apply to you as soon as the ordinance takes effect. The fines ordinance takes effect on adoption unless the mayor vetoes it within 10 days.
You can speak on the items at the meeting. It starts at 9 a.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, in the Commission Chambers at City Hall, 3500 Pan American Drive. The clerk’s notice says the ordinances can be read at the city clerk’s office or on the city’s meeting portal five days before the meeting. If the meeting cannot go ahead, the notice says it moves to 9 a.m. Tuesday, Nov. 24.
For where dogs can already run off leash, see our guide to dog-friendly Miami. For who runs what at City Hall, see who to call at City Hall.
Have your say